When it comes to roofing materials, organic shingles have a unique set of characteristics that set them apart from their fiberglass counterparts. While organic shingles may have been popular in the past, the rise of fiberglass shingles has led many homeowners to question the repairability and durability of organic options. In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of organic shingles and whether they can be effectively repaired.
Organic Shingles: A Closer Look
Durability in Cold Climates
One of the key advantages of organic shingles is their increased durability in cold climates. Due to their thicker, flexible, and double-asphalt layer, organic shingles can often withstand the harsh conditions of winter better than fiberglass shingles. This makes them a more suitable choice for homeowners in regions with extreme cold temperatures and heavy snowfall.
Repairability
When it comes to repairing organic shingles, the news is mixed. While it is often possible to repair a damaged section of the roof rather than replacing the entire slope, the availability of matching organic shingles is becoming increasingly scarce. As these shingles are no longer manufactured, homeowners may find it challenging to find the necessary materials to seamlessly blend in a repair. However, in some cases, it may be possible to find stockpiles of commonly used organic shingles from suppliers, allowing for more targeted repairs.
Fiberglass Shingles: A Modern Alternative
Fiberglass shingles have become the dominant choice in the roofing industry, largely due to their improved performance and durability. These shingles are lightweight, yet strong, and are less prone to distortion and moisture absorption over time. Additionally, fiberglass shingles are generally easier to repair, as they are more widely available and can be more easily matched to existing materials.
The Bottom Line
While organic shingles can offer increased durability in cold climates, their repairability is becoming increasingly challenging due to the discontinuation of their production. Homeowners with organic shingles may need to weigh the pros and cons of repairing their existing roof versus considering a full replacement with fiberglass shingles, which offer a more modern and reliable solution. Ultimately, the decision will depend on the specific condition of the roof and the homeowner’s priorities.